Top

Dark Souls Review (Xbox 360)

Game Review: Dark Souls (360)
Release: October 2011
Genre: 3rd Person Action/RPG
Developer: From Software
Available Platforms: PlayStation 3, Xbox 360
Players: 1
MSRP: $60
ESRB Rating: Teen
Website: Dark Souls
Two years ago, Demon’s Souls sparked a small, loyal following that, seemingly overnight, grew into a large phenomena. Those in the know would speak of it in hushed tones, often labeling it with the “this one separates the men from the boys” label. It was lauded for its presentation, challenge, and, if not innovative, at least fairly unique online features. But even the game’s biggest supporters couldn’t ignore the game was plagued by several technical issues that seemed to actively fight against its design. It’s a shame, then, that Dark Souls, its spiritual successor from the same developer, From Software, is now on the shelves to great fanfare, and yet suffers the same issues.
The world of Dark Souls is a grim one. Set against a Gothic fantasy backdrop, the game plunges you into the role of a hollowed human; zombie-like in appearance and devoid of any shred of humanity. You begin in a prison that serves as something of a tutorial. For the uninitiated, Dark Souls is a third-person action game with RPG elements. Once you have a grasp on the basic elements, and take down the first of many giant bosses, you’re (literally) whisked away to the completely open world that comprises the main game. After a brief chat with a lonely NPC, you’re given your marching orders: there’s two bells one above, and one below. What happens when you ring them? Well, no one knows for sure, actually. To be blunt, story isn’t what you come to Dark Souls for.
No, what you come to Dark Souls for is the game play. There are ten classes to choose from at the start, each with varying stats and bonuses. For newcomers, I’ve found either the Pyromancer and Bandit best to start with. Regardless, most classes can handle both melee combat, and magic attacks (most, not all restrictions apply across the board). If you’re hoping to gain any kind of deeper understanding of the play mechanics, or even just what everything in the game does, you have to go down avenues that most games don’t deal with. With little to no explanation in-game, and a two-page instruction manual, Dark Souls encourages gaining info through online communities, Wiki’s, and other forms of research. The investment you have to make into playing this game is a steep one. Add to that a deep online part, filled with attacking or aiding other players, leaving notes in the world, joining clans and guilds, and you’ve got yourself a title packed with content. Most of which you won’t understand at first.
Visually, Dark Souls is absolutely gorgeous. There’s a rich color palate, diverse locations, and really interesting character designs. It shows a tremendous amount of growth from their earlier release a title filled mostly with shades of brown and grey, and dungeon after dungeon. The game is at its best when dealing with tension, which is almost constant. Around every corner could be another unseen foe or death trap, a fact that keeps you on edge from the moment you load your save. The game, just like its predecessor, has been compared to climbing Everest, and having gone through this twice over now, I mostly agree with that sentiment. The game play drives you forward despite the inherent frustration that comes with the ridiculous difficulty, and when you overcome a specific obstacle, you feel like you’ve conquered the world. This game is a beast.
That being said, there’s another side to the game. If Dark Souls chose game play over animation priority, could run at a stable frame rate, had a functioning camera, a capable targeting system, and explained its own rules, it would stand as one of the greatest action titles in recent years. As it is, Dark Souls is a game that sells itself on its tough-as-nails attitude and not its technical ability. The appeal is there, and it is most definitely a game you want to like, but in the end Dark Souls must stand up to the criticisms lobbed at every other retail product, and in that regard it fails on several fronts. Put simply, the way you get good at Dark Souls is by learning to compensate for what it does poorly. While the game serves up a very compelling experience, these issues can not be ignored.
Make no mistake, there is a high barrier of entry for Dark Souls. It is a game built on repetition, accepting your limitations, and grinding through the same scenarios dozens upon dozens of times. None of those things are the problem with this game. It’s that the game does not give you the tools or abilities to survive that grueling process that makes is such a maddening experience. Going under the assumption that you’re one to enjoy a game despite it’s flaws, by all means dive in you’ll be in for a treat. If, however, the thought of a game punishing you for playing it poorly while at the same time preventing you from playing it smart sounds like the opposite of why you play video games, steer clear.
– One of the hardest games out there in recent memory, partly due to bad design fundamentals.
– Visually stunning with a great overall presentation.
– Plays better than Demon’s Souls in several regards, but there’s still a lot of room for improvement.
6 out of 10

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • Smackybear

    Couldn’t disagree more.  This game fills me with a sense of wonder that i haven’t felt since i first played the original Legend of Zelda back in 1987 when i was 10 years old.

  • JayJay

    Totally agree with the review!  This game has many technical problems that most reviewers are simply ignoring for some reason.  This guy is spot on with his assessment.

  • Sha_caska

    Dude you really need to elaborate on your problems with the game so people who haven’t played it can actually understand what you’re talking about. 

    So far in my playing (about 20hrs and at Blighttown) the only problem I’ve had is the horrible framerate in this place. But other than that I haven’t really noticed anything wrong with the game as such. There’s been a few moments which are kind of annoying like running down the trunk of a tree and not being able to run back up and consequently falling to death… the wheel elevator took some getting used to too :P. My brother walked in and said the animation looked a bit ‘jerky’ but I couldn’t really notice that, but once I got the hang of it it’s fine. I’m thinking maybe my love for the game has definitely skewed my perspective but these things are more of an annoyance to me and don’t really detract all that much from the experience. 

    If the game shipped in a wholly unplayable sate like Rage for my computer at launch and took me 10hours to get running and even then it wasn’t working how it should… but for me Dark Souls is a pretty amazing game once you get the hang of how things work. Take a trip to a few forums/wikis and discussing how you beat a particular boss is actually pretty fun too! Usually I play games for their story so I have no idea how Dark Souls has managed to hook me so. Oh and I’d have to disagree with you on the graphics of Dark Souls. To me they’re good but not amazing. I’m playing it on a PS3 hooked up to a 27″ PC monitor and I have to say there are many better looking games out there. I haven’t played Demon Souls so maybe there’s a big improvement and that’s what you’re basing your judgement on? 

    One other thing, it must have taken you like at least 50hours to play though once and if you’ve done it twice then say 100 hours in total. How can you rate a game 6 out of 10 if you’ve played that long? I’d totally understand if in your scale 5 is an average game, 6-7 above average and 8-10 well above and amazing. But yea if so I’d love to know what your higher rated games are. This is the first article of yours I’ve read so forgive me if you’ve already been reviewing such games and you needn’t mention it again, I’ll have a bit of a look now. 

  • Pingback: Dark Souls Review (360) – spiritualbattlesblogs()

  • One man’s “bad design fundamentals” is another man’s “holy shit this game is amazing.”  I feel bad you don’t like it much.  Once you get sucked in there is nothing like it in all of gaming.  

  • EnglishSteetsam

    I thought this game was pretty easy

  • 2hot4u

    The guy is right. Great visuals, Everything else is shoddy. Multiplayer is almost non existant because it doesnt work well. Fail after fail if you even get lucky enough to even see someone to summon… Have not summoned anybody on NG+ so far and I’m at the final boss area. My first playthrough I summoned only a handfull of times and through both playthroughs been invaded twice… None and I mean none of the covenant invasion items have worked for me yet. Now Level 74. Game is a let down. O by the way, you can’t play with friends unless your lucky. You will read other places that you have to sit there and try over and over but it’s not always true. Me & my buddy have been trying since release date with no luck.

  • Whitebread40

    This is the best game I’ve played since the old playstation 2 (onimusha, monster hunter, final fantasy FTW!!!) most 360 games kinda suck tbh, too much focus on FPS’s these days.

  • Whitebread40

    This is the best game I’ve played since the old playstation 2 (onimusha, monster hunter, final fantasy FTW!!!) most 360 games kinda suck tbh, too much focus on FPS’s these days.

  • Jbig802

    This is goty for me. Well worth the $60. The game says “prepare to die” for a reason. The thing is tho most of those deaths are the players fault. You either learn the strat to kill or your going to pay for it. The entire experience playing dark souls gave me a feeling of awesomeness that I haven’t felt this entire generation. Feels like a nod to old school difficulty. Real gamers owe it to themselves to play dark souls. You wont be dissapointed.

  • Jbig802

    This is goty for me. Well worth the $60. The game says “prepare to die” for a reason. The thing is tho most of those deaths are the players fault. You either learn the strat to kill or your going to pay for it. The entire experience playing dark souls gave me a feeling of awesomeness that I haven’t felt this entire generation. Feels like a nod to old school difficulty. Real gamers owe it to themselves to play dark souls. You wont be dissapointed.

  • Jbig802

    This is goty for me. Well worth the $60. The game says “prepare to die” for a reason. The thing is tho most of those deaths are the players fault. You either learn the strat to kill or your going to pay for it. The entire experience playing dark souls gave me a feeling of awesomeness that I haven’t felt this entire generation. Feels like a nod to old school difficulty. Real gamers owe it to themselves to play dark souls. You wont be dissapointed.

  • John Mckinnon55

    Really tho, you have to think about it, would you rather have long load times (Duke Nukem Forever) or framerate problems im not saying this as an excuse it should be marked down for it, but not by 4 whole points

  • John Mckinnon55

    Really tho, you have to think about it, would you rather have long load times (Duke Nukem Forever) or framerate problems im not saying this as an excuse it should be marked down for it, but not by 4 whole points

  • John Mckinnon55

    Really tho, you have to think about it, would you rather have long load times (Duke Nukem Forever) or framerate problems im not saying this as an excuse it should be marked down for it, but not by 4 whole points